Welcome to Health Care POV | sign in | join
The Politics of Health Care

Is Gun Violence a Public Health Issue?

Published January 18, 2013 12:58 PM by Kelly Wolfgang
As reported on Newswise, the following is a statement by Jo Ivey Boufford, MD, president of The New York Academy of Medicine, one of the nation's oldest and most prestigious medical academies, on the seriousness of gun violence as a major public health issue. The statement is in response to deadly incidents of gun violence in Newtown, CT, Webster, NY, and the shooting of 15 individuals, three of whom died, during separate acts of gun violence in Chicago, IL on New Year's Day.

"As a nation, we can only improve the health of the public when we get our priorities straight. Recent acts of gun violence in Chicago, Webster, NY, and Newtown, CT cannot be ignored. Neither can the 31,000 Americans who die each year at the hands of a gun. This number exceeds the number of babies who die each year during their first year of life (25,000) or people who die from AIDS (9,500) or illicit drugs (17,000).

We institute protective measures enforcing speed limits and requiring the use of safety belts; we implement public health measures such as child vaccinations and regulations around the safety of food, drugs, and products. Yet guns escape this type of regulation despite their significant contribution to the mortality rate each year. We must view gun violence as a serious threat to the public's health if we want to reduce the number of deaths associated with guns.

We can start by banning the sale of assault rifles, high-capacity magazines, and other facilitators of mass murder. And we must allow government agencies like the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention to fully exercise their duties in both surveillance of the incidence and impact of gun violence, and in educating the public on steps for preventing death and injury through the use of firearms.

The evidence is clear, and we must now take action to protect our neighbors and ourselves from this devastating public health crisis."

In December, both the American Nurses Association and the American College of Emergency Physicians, two prominent and national healthcare organizations, issued calls for a ban on the sale of assault weapons.

Sister publication ADVANCE for Nurse Practitioners & Physician Assistants asked its readers, "Do you think it is the responsibility of healthcare provider organizations to urge this type of action?"

Here's what some readers had to say:

  • "We can all do our part. As nurses, as humans." - Teanne
  • "Just stand in a trauma unit for one night and come back and give me your answer." - Melissa
  • "Yes! Absolutely! It's everyone's responsibility to speak up for what they believe!" - Kelli
  • "Absolutely not. I have stood in the trauma unit for 15 years and taking away my legal guns, which I carry concealed because I am licensed to do so, and taking away my rifles, which I enjoy shooting responsibly, will do nothing to stop the common street thug with an illegal weapon, other than allow me no protection for myself and my property when I'm leaving the trauma unit at midnight, sitting at a red light, and getting jacked by said thug." - Dana
  • "Most of our ER staff is armed; we see what's out there. As the Boy Scouts say, be prepared. The bad guys will always find guns; we need to be able to defend ourselves." - Diana
  • "Absolutely. Prior trauma nurse here at Miami Dade County. Some individuals have no business having weapons. Period." - Teresa
  • "This is definitely not the responsibility of healthcare provider organizations. This is a civil liberty. I'm sure many members of the groups do not support a ban. These groups should focus on healthcare issues." - Rita
  • "Supporting mental illness awareness and research would be a wiser choice! Let's be honest, what health professional has not taken some form of weapon to work with them?" - Susan

Do you agree with Boufford's statement and the calls for action by the American Nurses Association and the American College of Emergency Physicians? Weigh in on the comments below.

Editor's note: We welcome your comments and topic suggestions; contact blog author Kelly Wolfgang at kwolfgang@advanceweb.com.

4 comments

Banning 'Assault Weapons' and high capacity magazines will not stop violent attacks any more than banning cocaine, methamphetamine, muggings, murder, theft, prostitution or bribery have brought any of these to a stop.  Taking weapons away from citizens will only give criminals even more of an advantage.  Equating second amendment RIGHTS with driving PRIVILEGES only confuses the issue.  They are in no way related, and should never be allowed to be compared in a serious debate.  Firearms can give smaller, weaker, or handicapped victims  the capability to protect themselves against larger, stronger, or drug using assailants.

Denny Logemann February 2, 2013 4:17 PM
MN

I think it is funny that everyone wants to get on the band wagon about guns. Lets band the gun, lets stop the people from owning guns. But I don't hear anyone getting on the band wagon to stop the tobacco companies that have caused millions of deaths from smoking. How come they have not been shut down!  Why haven't the car companies been stopped from making cars, cars kill people everyday, but nothing. Lets get into the abuse of alcohol, how many people have been hurt or killed. There is a lot of looking the other way on many things that could have and should be stopped, again nothing.  Guns go, next the freedom of speech.

Jim Young, Radiology - Ct tech, Hospital January 29, 2013 10:01 PM
Lake Havasu city AZ

I disagree that professional healthcare organizations should take a stand on this issue. Mankind has been unkind to each other since....well...forever! Ban the guns, melt them down and they will make a knife, a hammer, a nuclear war head. Man will sharpen a stick, throw a rock or use our fists. Guns are not the problem. Mental illness, rage, or jealousy are the things the healthcare profession should be focused on. Supporting research, finding cures and how to provide healthcare when the sick and wounded come through our doors.

Bad guys dont care who is against disarming America. Bad guys dont care about laws. Bad guys are going to be bad guys. If you give them a single shot rifle, they will pack more than one or modify it to shoot more than once. Bad guys will steal guns from the good guys (police). Bad guys will buy or steal assult rifles, banana clips or whatever it takes to be "The Bad Guy". PERIOD!

I have seen gun shot wounds. I've also seen people beaten, run over, killed or mamed from many more things than gun shot wounds. No matter what is banned or taken away, there will always be "bad guys" doing bad things to good people.  

I and many in the profesion own, carry and enjoy shooting and hunting activities. And I have a constitutional right to do so (for now).  In the land of the free (?), I dont need my professional organization speaking for me.

Rod January 29, 2013 4:49 PM
IA

I agree with the call for banning assault weapons. I don't believe that it will gain traction. People often react to situations that they perceive as uncontrollable will knee jerk reactions. This time ti is arming themselves to the teeth against an attacker the probably wil never materialize. Common sense is usually enough to protect most of us. I am a veteran and I have seen people die of GSW from military grade weapons. It is not pretty and it is something that one never forgets. People who are waiting to kill an assailant with their AR-15 will have to suffer the sight of seeing a human deserving or not die in front of them by their own hand. They will make statement to the investigators. Then they will clean up the mess. It may seem counter intuitive but we should not hide the hideous details of what being shot looks like ( the media most often blurs it or cuts prior to the act). We should also reveal what happens after, whether it is from the victim's perspective or the shooter's. The horror will impress most people of conscience.

Leon January 29, 2013 2:32 PM
Raleigh NC

leave a comment



To prevent comment spam, please type the code you see below into the code field before submitting your comment. If you cannot read the numbers in the image, reload the page to generate a new one.

Captcha
Enter the security code below: