Welcome to Health Care POV | sign in | join
It's a Rad World

GALLUP SURVEYS

Published October 20, 2012 1:29 PM by Matt Estrada

We all know about the economy and how it has changed the employment landscape over the past few years. Jobs have been scarce during this time, as a result of businesses and employers trying to figure out ways to cut costs of doing business. One particular cost cutting measure that has been implemented is to eliminate certain positions that are now considered unnecessary. The duties of the position then get passed on to an employee who survives the rounds of layoffs. As a result, employee leverage, which could be used in the past for an employee to earn a raise, is now simply a distant memory.

 

I do most of my work in the field of Nuclear Medicine as a contract for hire, and I have been doing that for several years now. I represent myself, so I don’t work for an agency. In my geographical location, as well as all over the country, jobs are quite scarce. Gone are the days when an experienced tech could find a job in a number of different settings (hospitals, clinics, private practices, etc.). When I first graduated in 1993, the situation was the same as it is now. It took me three months before I would earn an interview as a Nuclear Medicine Technologist.

 

The main difference between then and now is that in 1994, the job market suddenly exploded. I was flown to different cities to interview at a number of hospitals looking for nuclear techs. The field of Nuclear Medicine was alive and well. Strike that – it was booming. Having all your moving expenses paid, along with a sign-on bonus was quite the standard practice at the time.

 

Fast forward to 2012, and the signs of the economic recession are everywhere. This time, not only did the job market turn sour, but it continues to remain a glass of tea without any sweetener. I am constantly looking for a new opportunity in my field, so I keep track of any opportunities that may present themselves.

 

I recently applied for a regular staff position online four months ago. After completing the application and sending my resume, I was directed to a Gallup Survey. The survey asked a multitude of questions in regards to hypothetical situations and how I would respond in those situations. It was an attempt to learn more about me as a potential employee without ever speaking to anyone.

 

I answered each question, all the while wondering how anyone could truly rely on the survey to tell them about potential candidates for employment. The whole thing just seemed mechanical and generic to me. It was a harsh reminder that this is the sign of the times now. Did the employer turn to the Gallup Survey simply because they eliminated the person who would normally speak to each candidate in scheduling an interview? Did they employ the release of this person as a cost cutting measure?

 

Only once I finished the survey was my application considered completed. I was sent an email the very next day informing me that my application was received but denied at that time. I wasn’t given the chance to meet anyone in person to have the opportunity to answer their questions and ask a few of my own. The Gallup survey doesn’t take into account the candidate’s employment record. Does the candidate have a clean record? Does the candidate show a history of being an exemplary employee (always on time, staying late if necessary, and being great with patients)? The survey was more suited for hiring a robot, rather than a human being, but I suppose attitude towards patients and co-workers, reliability, time management and many other factors simply don’t matter anymore.

 

In 1993, the thing employers told me they wanted their candidates to have was experience in their field. Experience was deemed one of the most vital criteria candidates needed to have in their arsenal. In 2012, it seems experience is one of the things that will prevent you from being hired, simply because employers feel they can pay a new grad much less than someone with experience.

posted by Matt Estrada

2 comments

Thank you very much Nick. This has been my personal experience as of late with the saturated market here on the west coast. Great to hear from the other side.

Matt November 6, 2012 2:05 PM

Matt, you make alot of good points.  However, the experience that you had doesn't reflect the experiences in my region.  Yes, we have not bee effected as much as other places by the economy in Northern Virginia.  We do, however, have alot of graduates for not as many jobs.  I think many employers truly use techniques, such as behavioral interviewing, and face to face meetings to find out how potential employees would fit with your crew.  We try to hire folks that we have trained that we know would be a good fit, which may make it difficult for someone, such as yourself, who has traveled around extensively.  This may be seen by some employers as a red flag, as someone who might not stay if something better came along elsewhere.  Experience is very key in our field. I do believe that there are many good employers out there who use more than just a gallup survey to find the right employee.  Thanks for your contribution!

Nick Gimmi, Medical Imaging - Clinical manager, Inova November 6, 2012 8:05 AM
Alexandria VA

leave a comment



To prevent comment spam, please type the code you see below into the code field before submitting your comment. If you cannot read the numbers in the image, reload the page to generate a new one.

Captcha
Enter the security code below: