Welcome to Health Care POV | sign in | join
ADVANCE Perspective: Respiratory Managers

Dear Abby Advises Smoker on How to Refuse Quitting Advice

Published June 21, 2008 11:50 AM by Colleen Mullarkey

Nowadays, the pressure is on for smokers to quit - but some feel their habit and its health risks are no one's business but their own.

Dear Abby published a letter from "Not Ready to Kick the Butts in Kenosha," a smoker who was sick of hearing lectures about why he should quit. He asked how to politely tell the concerned individuals to butt out.

When people decide they need to lecture me on why I should quit, how should I politely respond that I don't need their advice? I will decide on my own when I am ready to quit and make the effort. I understand they are trying to help my overall health, but it's really none of their business.

Link

The advice sage reluctantly agreed with the distraught smoker, and other readers' reactions poured in. Dr. Steven in Reno said Not Ready to Kick the Butts had him smoking.

Please tell me if you think you'll ever receive letters signed "Not Ready to Get a Disability Check Every Month Because I Won't Quit," or "Not Ready to Let Everybody Else Pay 80 Percent of My $276,000 Hospital Bill," or "Not Ready to Let Everyone Else Pay $1,500 a Month for My Oxygen and Medications."

Another reader had this frightening anecdote to share:

A chain-smoking Marine Corps gunnery sergeant once told me: "Anyone can quit smoking. It takes a REAL man to risk lung cancer."

At least some other readers took respiratory health into account.

One asthma sufferer said the smoker should have more concern for those with respiratory diseases irritated by smoke, and a grief-stricken wife recounted the pain of watching cancer devour her husband. You can read all of the responses here, and feel free to leave your own in our comments section. 

 

1 comments

That's how graduate student and writer Paul Devlin started off his open letter to Michelle Obama at the end of April. He went as far as saying that the future of the free world and perhaps Barack Obama's campaign depends on him getting his nicotine fix:

June 26, 2008 11:48 AM

leave a comment



To prevent comment spam, please type the code you see below into the code field before submitting your comment. If you cannot read the numbers in the image, reload the page to generate a new one.

Captcha
Enter the security code below: