Welcome to Health Care POV | sign in | join
ADVANCE Voice: NP

DNP and Retail Health Discussed in Article

Published May 12, 2008 12:51 PM by Jennifer Ford

PhysiciansNews.com published an article titled "Growing Role of Nurse Practitioners" last week, which addressed the doctorate of nursing practice and retail health clinics, two "hot buttons" that many nurse practitioners have been concerned about recently.

The article explains the new requirement of a DNP degree as entry to practice by the year 2015, and describes the certification developed by Mary O. Mundinger and others at the Council for for the Advancement of Comprehensive Care (see the post about my interview with Dr. Mundinger).

The article's author, Christopher Guadagnino, stresses that these developments are not an indication that NPs want to start a turf war. Rather, they are simply a reflection of the expansion of curriculum that already exists in master's programs for NPs. He states that current curriculum has grown "to a level that constitute a doctoral degree in most other professions."

The article also notes that the importance of the issues of autonomy and collaboration will be eclipsed by the need for care. "The U.S. will need 40 percent more primary care physicians by 2020, according to ACP and AAFP projections." The supply of NPs cannot meet its demand, either. Only 6,000 NPs graduate yearly, according to the article, and those numbers will not nearly make up for the projected primary care shortage.

DNP competencies are listed in the article, with a caveat noted by Polly Bednash, executive director of the American Association of Colleges of Nursing: "We are not reconceptualizing the role of advanced practice nurses. ... It is clear that changing demands of practice require taking more coursework to stay safe and current."

A phyisican interviewed for the article says NPs "don't come close to the level of training" of physicians, and that "there has to be an understanding of that within the nursing profession."

Physician groups are working to enact or maintain legislation that keeps NPs from providing care to the best of their ability, such as collaborative practice laws and regulations on retail health clinics. Removing those barriers will provide more access to care, especially because of the rapid growth of the retail health industry. Take Care Health, for example, currently operates 168 clinics across the country, all staffed by NPs who are able to provide care and refer patients to other providers as necessary.

2 comments

I am getting a bit annoyed about physicians as a whole offering their opinion on our nursing degrees.  It's none of their concern.  I have NO interest whatsoever in becoming a physician.  I want to be the best nurse I can be. Being a nurse practitioner allows me to a productive member of a medical team that includes physicians. We have our own distinctive place in the medical field to complement what physicians are able to do. Physicians have no idea what the DNP offers and how we can help the medical field in general and the physician specifically. The AMA has a problem by us being able to use the term "doctor" once we get the DNP.  I wouldn't even use "doctor" in clinical practice because the nature of my caregiving is more personal, and cooperative than hiding behind the title, not to mention the fact that I do not want to confused with a medical doctor. We do not have the same training as medical doctors, but our contribution to the medical field does not require it. Our service would be to medicine in general either through administration, teaching, or clinical nursing practice or to physicians specifically if we worked in partnership with them to operate a successful practice.  We can change policies and hopefully contribute to how our population base is cared for.   By the way, I am blessed to work with doctors who are respectful, eager to teach, and thankful for the contributions that nurse practitioners provide.  Not all physicians are paranoid, arrogant jerks.

Brenda, FNP-BC May 20, 2008 11:44 PM

I am a little confused.  I am definitely not opposed to a DNP; however, before we tackle that issue shouldn't we address the issue of whether an RN program is a 2 year vs 4 year curriculum?  I think having 2 different degrees does more of a disservice to our profession and makes us less credible as than whether a nurse practitioner has a master's or a doctorate degree.  In the end, we are still a registered nurses.

Julie, endocrinology - ARNP May 20, 2008 9:27 PM
Orlando FL

leave a comment



To prevent comment spam, please type the code you see below into the code field before submitting your comment. If you cannot read the numbers in the image, reload the page to generate a new one.

Captcha
Enter the security code below: