Welcome to Health Care POV | sign in | join
First Year PA

Bearing Witness To Faith

Published July 10, 2013 7:48 AM by Harrison Reed
 My first mistake was trying to shake my patient's hand. She smiled, looked at mine and shook her head.

"We like you," my patient's friend said with a smile. She was standing at the patient's bedside in the intensive care unit. "But we don't touch."

Then I noticed their similar dresses, long and plainly designed with only solid, dark colors for decoration. Their traditional clothes, next to the beeping alarms and flashing lights of our ICU gadgets, looked like the result of someone meddling with a time machine.

The embarrassment from my initial infraction kept me from asking any more questions, though I had many. Where are you from? What do you believe? What can I do to treat you? What can't I do? I wouldn't gather until later, as the Yiddish phrases began tumbling out, that she was an Orthodox Jew.

"Can I listen to your lungs?" I asked my patient.

"Of course you may," she said. "Touching for medical care is fine."

Ah, now I was getting it.

Patients have a variety of beliefs that guide their daily activities and interactions with the world. They hold these beliefs as sacred, sacrificing all kinds of pleasures and conveniences and even social acceptance in order to follow their cultural guidelines. But when it comes to health, to medicine, we can brush all that aside, at least for the moment. A handshake was too intrusive, but my physical exam-much more intimate-was allowed for the sake of survival.

To me, that made perfect sense.

I encountered something like this once before. Last summer, when the heat of the day scorched on for hours into the evening, my patient collapsed. No one really knew why, but since she was so dehydrated it seemed like an easy fix. But I had wondered why this woman, already fragile from age and comorbid disease, abstained from food or drink on a day like today. The answer is only simple if you ask.

She had fasted for religious purposes, from sun up to sun down. The Muslim holiday of Ramadan fell during the longest days of summer, but that didn't stop the devout from practicing their faith.

Intrigued, I met with Muslim leaders in the community and with chaplains at my hospital. I learned that, according to Muslim beliefs, there were plenty of exemptions from the fasting requirement. One of the exemptions allows the sick to skip the fasting ritual. While my patient saw herself as an able-bodied woman of even stronger faith, medical providers like myself could suggest taking advantage of the exclusion. We just needed to open the conversation.

Yet again, it seemed that faith was willing to take a back seat to the medical needs of the faithful. As medical providers, we can stand proud and know that our care takes priority over eons of established religion. As a testament to the progress of the modern age, our judgment truly comes first.

Except when it doesn't.

Except when the patient in question isn't an Orthodox Jew or a Muslim, but a Jehovah's Witness. Except when maintaining his faith trumps all, even life itself. Except when he looks at you with soft eyes and tells you "No blood products, ever," and thanks you for obliging. Except when his hematocrit drops and he becomes dizzy and falls over. Except when he vomits a cascade of bright red blood down the front of his hospital gown and the color drains from his face.

Except when the one thing that can save his life is forbidden.

Then we merely stand aside and bear witness to faith.




We have carved deep into the second half of my first year as a professional physician assistant. This

October 3, 2013 4:34 PM

It is quite important to realize that self preservation at all costs is not always the right or best thing to do.  Not that life is not to be valued, but, at times, it is not to be valued above all else.  What would compromising on a core tenant of faith say about the quality of one's existence?  As was explained to me, the willingness to possibly die under these circumstances does not show a disregard for life, but the refusal of blood is based on a profound respect for it.  

Displays of faith by patients should be respected in a world that is often much too quick to compromise anyone or anything for the sake of self.

Levi Glesby July 28, 2013 1:09 AM

I really enjoyed your blog.  It was well written and portrays what we experience each day and how sometimes faith triumphs all, and maybe at the end of the day thats all we have, our faith.


Ava , PA-C July 14, 2013 10:17 PM

No need to apologize, I just thought I would help to clarify where your patient was coming from, being that I am from both the Orthodox Jewish world and the medical world.

Jenny Rizel July 14, 2013 5:41 PM


The supposition that religion would take a back seat to medical care was intended to take a facetious tone, as the final paragraphs show in a somewhat extreme sense that religious faith will trump the judgement of outsiders, like myself, to those who hold such faiths sacred.

My own ignorance was the vehicle to deliver this message, as my encounters with various religious beliefs have been a trial/error process through my medical career. The first two-thirds of this blog was intended to illustrate the often-taken viewpoint of the less-informed, like myself. The final third was intended to show that in my experiences, sometimes religious and medical views co-exist smoothly and sometimes they do not.

I apologize if that intended message was lost.

Harrison Reed July 13, 2013 12:20 AM

As an Orthodox Jew and a Physician Assistant student, I just want to clarify your statement about religion taking a back seat to proper health care. It is not that religion is taking a back seat, it is that religion, at least from the Orthodox Jewish perspective, puts an emphasis on health, and values life above everything else. In fact, according to our beliefs, if you neglect your health, and put religion above receiving the proper health care, then you are in fact violating the will of God.

Jenny July 11, 2013 5:10 PM

leave a comment

To prevent comment spam, please type the code you see below into the code field before submitting your comment. If you cannot read the numbers in the image, reload the page to generate a new one.

Enter the security code below:


About this Blog

Keep Me Updated