Welcome to Health Care POV | sign in | join
ADVANCE Book Club for Nurses

Reaching Past the Wire: Questions & Discussion

Published September 2, 2008 2:14 PM by Pam Tarapchak

There are so many things I admire about Lt. Col. Deanna Germain : her humbleness, tenacity, compassion, just to name a few. Her journey to Iraq and the dedication with which she did her job under the worst circumstances are testaments to the human spirit and her role as a nurse. Some questions I have for Germain after reading the story:

  1. Going into active duty, you were confident you would only serve 6 months because you were in a reserve unit. Then there was one delay, then two, then three. How did your feelings for the assignment and your work change throughout these uncertain times?
  2. Your description of the dangerous convoy ride to the prison was so engaging. At one point, you said, "This was a moment in my life worth remembering." What are your memories of your trip and the importance of recalling it later?
  3. At one point, you called Abu Ghraib home. Is this a testament to the power of resilience or just a way to cope?
  4. Do you ever think about where your patients are now? If they’re living or dead? Patients like Bassem.
  5. What got you through your time at Abu Ghraib and your tour of duty?

For other book club readers, how did you feel about the book?

5 comments

Having interviewed hundreds of healthcare professionals over the years, the one thing I hear from them more than anything is their desire to care for their patients in the way they would like their family members to be treated.

It’s hard to imagine this philosophy translating to a war zone, let alone a prison in a war zone. That’s what struck me most about Deanna Germain’s book. Truly caring for people means everyone — regardless of who they are or what they may or may not have done.

Stacey Miller, Associate Editor September 18, 2008 2:06 PM

One of the things that really struck me about Deanna's experiences were her role as a healer but her requirement that she carry a weapon at all times. Somehow it fascinated me that the rifle had to be discharged into a barrel of sand before entering any building. All part of safety, but what a bizarre juxtaposition for a nurse to be in -- weapon and stethoscope.

Gail Guterl September 17, 2008 4:51 PM

I just started reading this book and love it so far. I have never read about a nurse in the military so I was excited to look into this world. I am amazed at the conditions they worked under- I won't complain again.

Mary, Nursing & Quality - Asst. Director, Charlotte AHEC September 6, 2008 5:29 PM
Charlotte NC

I thought the book was wonderful.  A good choice for a nurse's book club.  I was moved by her difficult and dedicated effort to lift herself above any feelings of 'distaste' in caring for prisoners who may have been responsible for the death of fellow American soldiers.  The fact that she was able to remember the pledge that she took on her graduation 'to practice my profession faithfully.'   At the medical center where I work, we have a mantra: "patient first"   It's often very difficult, but it has to be done, and you are truly practicing your profession faithfully when you are able to do it.

Betsy Kenrick, Surgical Service - Staff Nurse, Boston Medical Center September 4, 2008 8:17 PM
Boston MA

After reading the book, I wondered how much more went on that couldn't be told due to security reasons.  The adjustment not only being sent to Abu Ghraib and all that was going on there, but the hard struggle readjusting to being home again shows what our men and women are going through that we don't always think about.  Lt. Col. Deanna Germain was truly a very couragous, compassionate nurse.

Joan, geriatrics - RN supervisor September 4, 2008 11:04 AM
Waukesha WI

leave a comment



To prevent comment spam, please type the code you see below into the code field before submitting your comment. If you cannot read the numbers in the image, reload the page to generate a new one.

Captcha
Enter the security code below: