Close Server: KOPWWW05 | Not logged in

Welcome to Health Care POV | sign in | join
Toni Talks about PT Today

Are Groups the Answer?

Published March 12, 2014 5:19 PM by Toni Patt

One of the take-home messages from the APTA Combined Sections Meeting last month was that more therapy is better. I think everyone agrees with that. What we can't agree on, or even figure out for that matter, is how to squeeze more therapy into an already overcrowded day. One suggestion was to utilize group therapy in addition to what we're already doing.

On the surface that sounds like a great idea. You can work with more patients with less staff. Group is even billable, although not for very much. When performed in addition to regular therapy, there would be a net increase in revenue. At least that's how it sounds. If a couple of groups were incorporated into the weekly schedule, we'd have more therapy.

I see two problems with the idea. First, who is going to staff the group? Generally everyone will have a full caseload. I don't know of one facility that allows overtime. Nobody has time in their schedule for extra therapy. Bringing in an extra person probably isn't feasible. Even with some revenue generated, the influx will not cover the salary of the staff needed to have the group.

The second problem is reimbursement, as in who will pay for it? Even if you somehow find the time and the staff, someone still has to pay for it. One suggestion was to have patients private pay for the group when provided on an outpatient basis. I don't know about everyone else, but at any given time at least one-third of my patients are non-funded. Many others are on a fixed income. Even if they want the therapy, they can't afford it.

You would need to have the group meet at least three times a week for it to have any meaningful impact. Multiply that by a few weeks and the cost rises quickly. If the cost is kept low, larger groups will be needed to offset expenses. Larger groups mean more staff. If you limit the number in the group, the cost will need to be higher. Many patients grumble about outpatient therapy copays. I can't see this going over any better on a large scale.

So we have a reasonable suggestion but no feasible way to implement it at this time. Obviously increasing the amount of reimbursement for our services would be a big help, but that isn't going to happen.

Until someone on the payer side realizes all the benefits of therapy on keeping costs down and decreasing length of stay, nothing will change. The same studies that say more is better also show how increasing the therapy actually decreases the bill and length of stay. Maybe they don't want to see it. Maybe they don't believe it. One reason our system is dysfunctional is because of the numerous groups and entities invested in keeping it the way it is.

Related Content

Over 13,000 Gather in Las Vegas for CSM!

The APTA calls it a new record for the association's showcase conference.


Wow, too early in the morning! "off the clock" and "completed" Sorry

Char McCoy April 2, 2014 6:58 AM

AH, The never ending push to increase efficiency with less labor hours. I'm beginning to feel like I did when I worked in Fast Food as a teen. Our company is now enforcing mandatory of the clock lunch breaks. (In my state it is not required) They know that this will allow unpaid labor time, so that documentation, filing etc. can get completeted

Char, Program manager/PTA April 2, 2014 6:54 AM

You must be talking outpatient or Home Health, because you sure can't do more therapy in a Nursing Home or a Rehab Facility. Group Therapy counts against you now and as you said it pays very little. Let's see 49.6% of Amercians work out for 30 minutes 3 days a week.

18.5% work out 30 minutes 2 days a week. The Majority of our patients are 70 plus years old and the reason they are there to see us is they don't fall in any of these categories. They haven't worked out in years when you talk to most of them. Then they come to a Rehab program and are asked to do more exercise than most of the PTs who treat them do in a week. 5 to 6 days a week for 30 minutes or more 2 X a day. Then you throw them on a Bicycle and have them pedal for 15 minutes or you put weights on their legs and arms and expect them to walk 50 feet or more or do 10 to 30 reps and sometimes even more I have seen. I talk to therapists everyday who don't do that much exercise in a month, must less a week. Then you are telling me that out of Combined Sections Meeting that "MORE IS BETTER"!

Hey, Go for it, but please make sure, I'm not one of your patients.

Donald Meadows, Physical Therapy - PTA March 13, 2014 11:08 PM
Robertsdale AL

leave a comment

To prevent comment spam, please type the code you see below into the code field before submitting your comment. If you cannot read the numbers in the image, reload the page to generate a new one.

Enter the security code below:


About this Blog

Keep Me Updated